top of page

Understanding the Difference between a Wholesaler, an MGA, and a Broker

The insurance sector comprises several players, each with a distinct function. Customers purchase insurance straight from retail agents. Wholesalers don't deal directly with consumers; instead, they work behind the scenes with insurance providers to arrange customized coverage for the insured. Managing General Agents, or MGAs, are similar. Although they serve consumers directly to meet their requirements, they primarily represent the carrier. Another kind of intermediary is a broker. They take on the role of specialists by advising clients on what kind of insurance they want, after which they shop around for the best deals from various insurance providers. Let’s dig into these terms further.


What’s a wholesale broker?

Wholesale brokers act like connectors in insurance. They work between regular insurance brokers (retail brokers) and insurance companies (carriers). Retail brokers deal directly with clients, while wholesale brokers don't.


Wholesale brokers are specialists. They often have deep knowledge about a specific type of insurance, unusual coverage, or a particular local market. This expertise helps both insurance companies and regular brokers.


Regular brokers establish a rapport with their consumers. They receive a commission from wholesale brokers who assist them in finding the unique and appropriate insurance, such as that needed for a small cafe. Wholesale brokers find consumers for insurance carriers, saving them the trouble of doing it themselves. Everyone gains from this arrangement in the end.


Wholesale Brokers vs MGAs

In the insurance industry, obtaining coverage involves several different parties. MGAs (Managing General Agents) and wholesale brokers are two examples. Although both can be classified as wholesale brokers, their duties differ significantly. Not all wholesale brokers are MGAs, but all MGAs are wholesale brokers. In the same way, not all rectangles are squares, and not all squares are rectangles.


MGAs: The More Involved Wholesale Broker


An MGA functions as an extension of the insurance carrier, with the same powers to undertake many of the firm's regular functions, including pricing setting, coverage approval (binding), determining eligibility for coverage, processing claims, and underwriting.


  • MGAs are employed by the insurance carrier (the insurer), not the policyholder.

  • It is the insurance carrier, not the MGA, assumes the risk.

  • MGAs can communicate with clients to learn about their needs, but their main goal is to make sure the client has a policy that satisfies the demands of the insurer.


Choosing Between an Insurance Broker and MGA

Think of a traditional agent or broker as a salesperson for the insurer. They explain different policies to customers and help them find the best coverage. MGAs do not interact with clients directly. Instead, they collaborate with brokers, agents, and insurance carriers. MGAs have unique authority as, unlike other agents/brokers, they can determine whether to approve an individual for insurance (a process known as underwriting). Selecting the appropriate insurance might be difficult. Insurance brokers and managing general agents are two comparable actors in the market (MGAs). Let's examine the main distinctions to assist you in selecting the appropriate approach.


Differences Between a Broker vs. and MGA
Differences Between a Broker vs. and MGA

Who They Serve: As a customer, you are the one that an insurance broker serves. Their responsibility is to locate the most affordable coverage that meets your demands. It is their responsibility to provide MGAs, which represent insurance companies/carriers. They handle some of the insurer's tasks, like finding clients and processing applications. However, they still try to get you a good deal.


Level of Involvement: Both brokers and MGAs typically earn commissions from their insurers. But MGAs might have a deeper stake in the game. Sometimes, they share the profit or loss from the policies they sell. This can incentivize them to be more selective about who they insure.


Expertise: As generalists, brokers provide a range of insurance products from different providers. MGAs, on the other hand, frequently serve a specific industry or specialize in a particular area of insurance.


Opening a Shop: Becoming an insurance broker is less complicated. Establishing an MGA requires more time and work since they handle additional duties on behalf of the insurer.


Benefits of Working with MGAs for Insurance Agents

The relationship between insurance agents and managing general agencies (MGAs) could prove advantageous. MGAs provide more products and specialized knowledge, serving as a middleman between brokers and insurers.


Access to specialized markets: MGAs concentrate on particular insurance categories, enabling agents to connect with customers who have particular requirements that conventional insurers would not be able to meet. These specialty markets may be defined by sector (e.g., technology or construction), kind of risk (e.g., cyber liability), or even attributes of the target market (e.g., high-net-worth people). Because of their extensive expertise in these niche industries, MGAs can identify unique risks and provide insurance solutions that meet those needs.


Tailored insurance schemes: MGAs can modify regular insurance plans to better suit a customer's needs. Because of this flexibility, coverage may be more precisely customized to the customer's needs. For instance, a restaurant-focused MGA could be able to design a policy that includes coverage for liquor liability, slip-and-fall incidents, and food spoilage.


Less complicated underwriting procedure: For some policies, MGAs are in charge of both selling and risk assessment (underwriting). For agents, this expedites the process, allowing them to obtain bids and bind coverage more quickly. MGAs can underwrite policies faster and more effectively than typical insurers since they are specialists in specific fields. When agents are operating under pressure, this could be a big benefit.

2 views0 comments

Comments


bottom of page